Elden Ring DLC Best Throwing Pot Tier List (Shadow of the Erdtree)

Now there are all 19 throwing pots in Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree, some of them stand out due to their utility and effectiveness in various combat scenarios. Here we rank all of them with the Elden Ring DLC Throwing Pot Tier List to help you pick up the best one for your gameplay!

Elden Ring DLC Throwing Pots Tier List - Best Throwing Pots Ranked in Shadow of the Erdtree

In Elden Ring, throwing pots are a type of consumable item that players can craft and use to deal damage, apply status effects, or create tactical advantages in combat. The Shadow of the Erdtree DLC introduces 19 new throwing pots, many of which are Hefty pots, larger versions of regular pots that offer increased damage, larger AOE, knockback effects, and higher stance damage. However, they come with a longer animation, making them risky to use. By effectively using these powerful throwing pots, you can gain a significant tactical advantage in Elden Ring, making challenging encounters more manageable. In this guide, we'll rank these pots from best to worst based on their utility in PVE and crafting difficulty.

• 1. Hefty Rot Pot (S Tier)

The Hefty Rot Pot is exceptional due to its ability to apply the best version of Scarlet Rot, which deals 30% damage over 90 seconds. This pot builds up 400 rot, significantly more than the 300 rot buildup from regular rot pots. The Hefty Rot Pot's major advantage is its ease of farming, as it requires Scarlet Buds, one of the easiest materials to obtain in the DLC. Despite the longer animation time, the pot's high damage output and universal applicability make it the top choice for any build.

• 2. Hefty Rock Pot (S Tier)

The Hefty Rock Pot is a physical damage pot with an S scaling in strength, making it one of the highest damage-dealing pots. It offers a substantial 15 stance damage, equivalent to a stone grenade, and benefits from good synergy with strength builds. The materials required for crafting, round rocks, are easy to farm. This pot is ideal for strength builds as it provides a reliable projectile option, with its high damage and stance damage making it a strong choice.

• 3. Hefty Ranor Pot (S Tier)

The Hefty Ranor Pot scales with both faith and intelligence, causing it to shoot skulls similar to the Ancient Death Rancor spell upon impact. This pot boasts high tracking and damage, making it potentially the highest damaging pot in the game. It also provides significant stance damage (13-14) and consumes only 9 FP. Though it requires a high-level faith and intelligence build to maximize its potential, its overall effectiveness and ease of use make it a top-tier pot.

• 4. Hefty Lightning Pot (S Tier)

The Hefty Lightning Pot is a dexterity-based pot that excels in dealing damage and knockback. It scales well with dexterity and offers a significant AOE. The materials for crafting it are easy to farm, and it is particularly effective in water or when it’s raining, enhancing its damage output. This pot is an excellent choice for dexterity builds that lack a projectile option, providing a reliable and powerful AOE attack.

• 5. Red Lightning Pot (S Tier)

The Red Lightning Pot shares similarities with the Hefty Red Lightning Pot but is more effective against groups of enemies due to its chain lightning effect. While it does less damage than the Hefty version, its larger AOE and ability to chain between multiple enemies make it exceptionally useful in crowd control situations. The materials for this pot are also easy to obtain, making it a practical choice for dexterity builds.

• 6. Hefty Magic Pot (A Tier)

The Hefty Magic Pot is an intelligence-based pot that deals pure magic damage. It scales with intelligence, providing a high-damage, knockback effect, and efficient FP usage. While spells are generally more efficient for intelligence builds, this pot can outperform many spells in terms of damage and FP consumption when augmented with the Companion Jar and Great Jar Helmet. It serves as a solid AOE projectile option for intelligence builds.

• 7. Hefty Fire Pot (A Tier)

The Hefty Fire Pot is a strength-based pot that deals fire damage and offers knockback effects. It is particularly effective against enemies weak to fire. While the Hefty Rock Pot might be a better overall choice for strength builds, the Hefty Fire Pot excels in specific scenarios where fire damage is advantageous. It provides a reliable fire-based projectile option for strength builds, especially against fire-weak enemies.

• 8. Hefty Fly Pot (A Tier)

The Hefty Fly Pot is a bleed-based pot that summons blood flies, causing significant blood loss buildup over time. It is effective against stationary or large enemies due to its AOE. However, its effectiveness diminishes against mobile enemies that can easily move out of the AOE. It is best used in poison builds that aren’t focused on bleed, providing an additional option for proccing bleed on enemies.

• 9. Eternal Sleep Pot (B Tier)

The Eternal Sleep Pot is an enhanced version of the regular sleep pot, inflicting internal sleep that keeps enemies asleep even when hit. It is more effective against specific bosses and trash mobs, consuming twice as much FP. The materials for crafting this pot are easily farmed, making it a viable option for situations where putting enemies to sleep is advantageous. However, its situational nature limits its overall utility.

• 10. Hefty Oil Pot (B Tier)

The Hefty Oil Pot applies oil to enemies, increasing their fire damage taken by 65% on the next hit. This pot is beneficial in scenarios where a significant fire attack follows the oil application. However, its single-use debuff and risky long animation make it less practical. It is best used in conjunction with powerful fire-based attacks, providing a situational but potent damage boost.

• 11. Hefty Furnace Pot (B Tier)

The Hefty Furnace Pot is designed to counter furnace golems and scales with faith. It provides some of the highest damage among pots and does not consume FP. However, the materials required for crafting are finite per playthrough, limiting its use. It is best reserved for specific enemies, making it a powerful but situational tool.

• 12. Hefty Fatid Pot (C Tier)

The Hefty Fatid Pot procs deadly poison quickly, making it highly effective against bosses. However, it is hard to craft and procs poison on the user as well. Despite its quick poison buildup, better alternatives like the deadly poison perfume bottle exist. This pot is situational and best used when other poison-proccing options are unavailable.

• 13. Hefty Volcano Pot (C Tier)

The Hefty Volcano Pot creates a lingering AOE that deals damage over time. It can be one of the highest damaging pots due to its sustained damage effect. However, it offers less stance damage compared to other Hefty pots, and the materials required are harder to farm. This pot is best used for sustained damage in specific scenarios.

• 14. Hefty Freezing Pot (C Tier)

The Hefty Freezing Pot procs Frost, causing enemies to take 10% more damage and debuffing them for 20 seconds. It offers a higher frost buildup (400) compared to regular freezing pots (380), but the difference is minimal. The longer animation and easier farming of regular freezing pots make the Hefty version less practical. It is best used for proccing frost, but regular pots are generally more efficient.

• 15. Hefty Poison Pot (C Tier)

The Hefty Poison Pot provides high poison buildup but is less effective compared to deadly poison. While its materials can be infinitely bought, making it easier to craft, the overall utility of poison is limited. This pot is situational and less desirable compared to other status effect pots.

• 16. Hefty Red Lightning Pot (C Tier)

The Hefty Red Lightning Pot is a dexterity-based pot with knockback effects. While it deals more damage than regular lightning pots, the lack of chain lightning effect and harder crafting materials make it less practical. It is best used in specific scenarios where knockback is beneficial.

• 17-19. Frenzied Flame Pots (D Tier)

Frenzied Flame Pots inflict Madness, which is largely ineffective in PVE. The pots require multiple throws to proc Madness, and NPCs often dodge them. Despite scaling with every stat except Arcane and having high damage potential, their difficulty in farming and limited utility make them less desirable. They are best used against NPCs, but even then, their practicality is questionable.

Each pot has its unique strengths and weaknesses, making them more or less useful depending on the situation. The Hefty Rot Pot stands out as the best due to its high damage over time and ease of crafting, while Frenzied Flame Pots rank the lowest due to their limited utility in PVE and difficulty in farming materials. Choose your pots wisely based on your build and the enemies you face.